A few thoughts on the Food Halls of Manhattan: a view from Queens

The growing popularity of Food Halls –  some of the city’s best, typically individually owned food options packed into one cavernous, clamorous space – is undeniable. There is an air of excitement around these places, an obvious energy, and easy access to some really truly great eats. Most recently, I visited Gotham West Market twice in one week just to try Ivan Orkin’s Slurp Shop, Seamus Mullen’s El Colmado, and Blue Bottle’s excellent coffee, all in one place, and a short jaunt from the tourist-commuter hell corridor of Midtown where I work.

When I first heard about Anthony Bourdain’s proposed plan to build a large scale food hall focused on street food from all over the world, I remember feeling a weird pang of hope that it would be in Flushing, Queens or Sunset Park, Brooklyn. After all, a food hall of this type would do well nestled amidst places like Flushing’s Golden Shopping Mall, New World Mall, and other places that, well, already function as wildly popular food halls. Inevitably though, we learned it would be in Manhattan, likely in the Financial District, an obvious attraction for local New Yorkers and tourists alike.

The related question that kept coming up for me is, do privatized, curated food halls like the one Bourdain has proposed for Manhattan discourage tourists and locals from traveling throughout the five boroughs to experience food within a neighborhood context?

By centralizing access to food that New Yorkers typically have had to travel from block to block, neighborhood to neighborhood, borough to borough in order to obtain all under one roof in Manhattan, are we encouraging a food trend that might hurt our neighborhoods in the future? A potential reduction in business, a lessening of foot traffic, and perhaps most troublingly, an eventual disruption to the organic, historical, hyper-local contexts in which so many food cultures have thrived throughout New York City could all result.

Put another way, instead of a neighborhood being known for a particular cuisine (or cuisines), there are food emporiums, veritable theme parks of food, popping up left and right as an alternative destination. Can Arthur Avenue in the Bronx coexist with Eataly? Or does one draw people, money, resources, away from the other? I really don’t have an answer, but think that it may be well worth asking the question.

Additionally, well-curated and carefully assembled food halls may reduce the likelihood that you will have a hit-or-miss meal. But they also diminish the possibility that you will try something new (either hit or miss), that you will go someplace new, see parts of the city you haven’t seen before, and immerse yourself in the complex, not always neat or perfectly packaged, but always thrilling and rewarding food worlds of New York City.



3 thoughts on “A few thoughts on the Food Halls of Manhattan: a view from Queens

  1. I personally do not believe that the surge of Manhattan (and now Brooklyn) food halls poses any real threat to businesses located in outer-borough ethnic enclaves. Why? Because very few tourists, and even centrally-located New Yorkers, are willing to venture out to those areas to begin with. I would guess that 80-90% of the business generated by the New World Mall comes from people residing within Queens, or people of Chinese/Taiwanese descent living in other parts of the city.

    So, I do think that places like Arthur Avenue and Eataly can peacefully coexist because they cater to entirely different populations. Eataly is great for tourists, people who work/live in the city, and anyone else who don’t mind spending a little extra money on their pasta. Meanwhile, Arthur Avenue is a solid choice for anyone who lives nearby or is willing to take a really, really long train ride. (I’m glad I made the trek, however I could just as easily buy cheap fresh spaghetti from Cassinelli.)

    I guess that’s why I love Astoria — it is a great “buffer neighborhood” between the gentrification of Manhattan and the ethnic wonderland of Queens. That said, I am actually kind of excited about Anthony Bourdain’s street-food hall. Like most it-destinations I will probably visit once, wait 20 minutes in line to buy a taco, and then run away screaming. :-p

    • Good take on this! However, I do think that there are a lot of opportunities, especially with Airbnb, etc., to decentralize Manhattan as the perceived center of NYC’s food culture in the minds/experience of tourists (and even, perhaps, everyday New Yorkers?). I personally think that shift from monolithic center to myriad margins might benefit local neighborhoods financially, allowing beloved long time businesses to thrive instead of shutter.

      As an aside, your blog is fun! Are you on Twitter?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s